E-mail Story   Print Story
  Comments (3) Total Thursday Apr. 17, 2014
LETTER: Dead Trees Play Crucial Role in Forest Ecosystems
The U.S. Department of Agriculture is wasting $10 million dollars trying to apply a crop-based biomass utilization model to our rugged and remote national forests! While Cool Planet Energy Systems’ turning of farm waste into gasoline and biochar may have merit, it does not apply well to dead trees on remote public lands.

In a recent article, Montana State University's Peter Kolb gets it wrong by calling dead trees “carbon waste.” Dead trees are not corn stalks. They continue playing a crucial role in maintaining forest ecosystems, from providing critical wildlife habitats to returning carbon and nutrients to the forest soil. While Kolb points out the economic problems of getting dead trees to a biomass facility, he wrongly implies that ecological concerns are merely “policy issues” to be overcome.

Cool Planet’s web site indicates that, by applying heat to biomass in the absence of oxygen, one-third of the carbon is released into the air, one-third is bottled up in biofuels, and one-third is sequestered in biochar returned to the soil. Cool Planet claims its process is “carbon negative” and implies the more we drive our cars using its biofuels, the more we are helping cool the planet - by essentially burying its plant life as biochar.

Last November, 41 scientists warned the Environmental Protection Agency that using trees as biomass energy is harmful and quite different than using farm crop waste. In October, 250 scientists told Congress dead trees in burned forests are “one of the most ecologically important and biodiverse habitat types in western conifer forests.”

How much of USDA’s $10 million will go to scientists finding forest ecosystems are capable of recycling their own carbon? How much will go to silence them as massive federal subsidies are created to grind those ecosystems up?

Keith Hammer, Chair
Swan View Coalition, Kalispell
On 01-07-14, craigrc commented....
who the hell made this guy an authority on forest health,hope he gets it by a widowmaker in his dead forest,hey keith those bettle kill trees in helena are really beautiful,but can’t cut those down can we!
Kellyn Brown
Kellyn Brown12h
The latest Best of Preps edition is out. Great photos by @gl_photo http://t.co/RYiLUVGOY8 #mtscores http://t.co/yM5hxluamZ
Dillon Tabish
Dillon Tabish9h
Groups Criticize Governor Over Forest Priorities http://t.co/jcYrryw3oe Original story by @TribLowdown here: http://t.co/du8AWgWoj2 #mtnews
Molly Priddy
Molly Priddy7h
@mallelis What do you ladies use to wrap your Lembas bread? I can't find organic mallorn leaves anywhere
Tristan Scott
Tristan Scott16h
Your Survival Guide To Coachella http://t.co/hlyov5FZjv via @IamJessicaLima http://t.co/0b5csXZiN8
Flathead Beacon
FB Headlines8h
Groups Criticize Governor Over Forest Priorities http://t.co/DsjY7nOJbT